Law at work 2020 - the trade union guide to employment law (July 2020)

Chapter 12

Early retirement benefits

[ch 12: pages 474-475]

Unlike pensions, early retirement provisions and pension enhancements triggered by dismissal before retirement age, for example, accelerated pension benefits on redundancy, do transfer (unless they relate to ill-health or invalidity). This was confirmed in a landmark case brought by UNISON concerning rights for over-50s:

An NHS scheme entitled redundant employees aged over 50 to an early retirement pension. The ECJ ruled that early retirement benefits are not “old-age, invalidity or survivors’ benefits” and are therefore not covered by the pensions exclusion. Instead, these contract terms transfer to the new employer.

Beckmann v Dynamco Whicheloe Macfarlane [2002] All ER 5

https://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/EUECJ/2002/C16400.html

The Beckmann case was followed in Martin and others v South Bank University Case C-4/01 [2004] IRLR 74. These rulings apply to pensions in both the public and the private sector (Proctor & Gamble Limited v SCA [2012] EWHC 125).

Early retirement benefits triggered by ill-health do not transfer to the new employer under TUPE because “invalidity benefits” are specifically excluded from the transfer by the Acquired Rights Directive.


This information is copyright to the Labour Research Department (LRD) and may not be reproduced without the permission of the LRD.