LRD guides and handbook May 2019

Law at Work 2019 - the trade union guide to employment law

Chapter 14

The main hearing 





[ch 14: page 483]

Tribunal hearings take place in public. Very occasionally, for example, in some cases involving allegations of sexual misconduct, a tribunal may agree to anonymity or to a restricted reporting order. 





Early on, the tribunal allots a fixed number of days for the trial. Judges are not supposed to allow cases to overrun their allotted time and can cut off too long or unnecessary oral evidence, questioning and submissions, or stop a party who has used up their allotted time. 





Tribunals must show an absence of bias and allow both parties to state their case and respond to any allegations (Williams v Real Care Agency Ltd [2012] UKEATS/0051/11/BI). They must decide the case based on the evidence before them and not take into account evidence that was not considered in the hearing (East of England Ambulance Service v Sanders [2014] UKEAT 0217/14/1710). 





Claimants have the right to be represented by an individual of their choice (Bache v Essex CC [2000] IRLR 251) or to represent themselves. 





Judges must ensure that as far as practical, parties are on an “equal footing”. However in practice there is often significant inequality of both representation and legal resources. Judges must balance each side’s capabilities and offer support to unrepresented litigants where needed, but they must also remain impartial and are not supposed to advise badly represented or unrepresented litigants how best to conduct their case (Drysdale v The Department of Transport [2014] EWCA Civ 1083). All litigants, even those without representation, must make their own case by producing evidence, explaining their arguments and cross-examining the employer’s witnesses. The tribunal will not make their case for them (see, for example, Royal Mail Group Ltd v Efobi [2019] EWCA Civ 18). 





It is a criminal offence to record a tribunal hearing, for example, using a smart phone. This includes preliminary hearings over the phone.